Department of Education and youth organisations


Photo on 14-08-2014 at 19.33 #3
By Youth Ambassador, Hugo Garvey

Seeing a teacher outside of school is usually an embarrassing experience, but is even worse if the teacher works at a school you’ve dropped out of. That is what Louise Bromley, now the director of the YP collective – an employment platform for young people out of work- found out when she saw her maths teacher at the shop where she found her first job. The worst part, she explains, was that she was ‘supposed to go to Oxford’ but had ‘ended up in Pet Supermarket instead’. This was one of the many experiences shared at the meeting on careers guidance attended by the Careers and Enterprise Company – a taxpayer funded organisation to broker links between schools and businesses-, the Department for Education, YEUK and the YP collective on Tuesday the 17th of March, all of which reinforced one point: that careers guidance in the UK has failed a generation of young people.

The meeting made clear that the failure of careers education is due to a variety of reasons. 2015-03-17 18.48.22First, there’s not enough of it. Several of the delegates from YEUK and the YP collective struggled to remember any careers guidance, and those who did found it to be limited at best. Darren, who also works for the YP collective, found that the just a single careers guidance meeting -the norm in many state schools- was useless, and that only working with young people over an extended period of time produced results. A survey carried out by Youth Employment UK also found that 42% of the respondents hadn’t even had one such meeting, and that only 7% of respondents had been advised about apprenticeships.

Second, much of the careers guidance is outdated. Careers education is currently geared toward the labour market of previous generations, in which most would stay in the same job their whole life, as oppose to today’s situation where it is common to switch entire fields multiple times over the course of a career. As such, young people often lack soft skills, such as the ability to network or present themselves to an employer, due to the focus within careers guidance on job-specific skills and advice.

YEUK Ambassador Shakira sharing her careers education experiences.
YEUK Ambassador Shakira sharing her careers education experiences.

Finally, the guidance that has been offered is almost universally uninspiring. A common complaint among the attendees was that they lacked a ‘purpose’ or ‘drive’ in their early years. Careers guidance officers rarely command any respect and several of the attendees reckoned this is because they usually work in isolation from employers, reducing their legitimacy as someone who understands the labour market. Most attendees agreed that more employers need to come to schools to inspire students. The outdated view that students will most likely stay in the same line of employment throughout their working life also reduces young people’s motivation to prepare for their future by forcing them to choose a career path before they understand what they’re interested in.

So careers education seems to have more weaknesses than strengths. With youth unemployment stubbornly high despite the economic recovery, the newly set up Careers and Enterprise company have their work cut out.

YEUK Says: It is great news that the new Careers and Enterprise Company want to hear the views of young people as they look at improving the careers landscape.  We hope to build on this relationship and provide further support to the company with our #YouthVoice

If young people are looking for careers inspiration or support we recommend Plotr a great careers inspiration website and the National Careers Service who can provide free telephone support.

Tagged in: , , , , , , , , , ,

Are You Aged 14-24?
Get FREE Young Professional Training
Are You An Employer?
Get youth employment expert help

For more information, please email or call 01536 513388.

Looking for Youth Friendly Employers?

Find out more about some of the organisations offering high quality training and work opportunities to young people. Your next dream role could be just a click away…

Latest Articles

See more

The cost of mental health support at work – should employers invest in mental health?

Mental health in the workplace: a new report from Deloitte and the charity Mind makes the case that investing in […]

Futures at Stake 2020 report surveys young people, teachers and employers about youth futures

The Prince’s Trust and Govia Thameslink Railway have launched the Futures At Stake 2020 report surveying young people, teachers and employers […]

Dream jobs report – Are young people’s career aspirations narrowing?

The OECD have launched new research exploring young people’s career choices. The Dream Jobs? research findings indicate that young people […]

UK labour market statistics

Labour Market Overview: January 2020

Below you will find the latest labour market statistics for January, the data in this piece is taken from the […]